There’s something quietly magical about Saint Martin — an island split between two nations, where you can sip French wine at lunch and stretch out on a Dutch-side beach by afternoon.

We chose to stay on the French side near Marigot, drawn by its European charm, slower pace, and unmistakable sense of place. It delivered everything we were hoping for—and more.

Disclaimer: This page contains affiliate links. Please see our disclaimer policy here.

Why Stay on the French Side (Marigot Base)

If you’re after culture, food, and a more relaxed Caribbean rhythm, the French side is the clear winner.

Mornings started with flaky pastries from local bakeries, afternoons included browsing the excellent wine selection at Le Gout Du Vin and selecting the perfect cheese pairing from Le Comptoir des Fromages. Evenings often turned into long, lingering dinners followed by walks on the beach. There’s an authenticity here that feels closer to the south of France than a typical Caribbean resort strip.

Our standout dining experience was La Terrasse Restaurant — the kind of place that turns a meal into a memory. We loved it so much, we went back more than once. Expect refined French-Caribbean cuisine, thoughtful wine pairings, and a setting that makes you want to stay long into the evening.

Our Favourite Beaches on Both Sides

French Side Favourite: Petit Plage (Grand Case Area)

Tucked near Grand Case, Petit Plage quickly became one of our favourite beaches on the island.

It’s everything you want in a Caribbean beach without the crowds—clear water, soft sand, and a peaceful atmosphere. Grand Case itself is known as the culinary capital of the Caribbean, so it’s easy to pair a beach morning with an unforgettable lunch.

Dutch Side Favourite: Mullet Bay Beach

On the Dutch side, Mullet Bay Beach completely won us over.

Yes, the Dutch side (Sint Maarten) feels more developed and less culturally rich, but this beach is worth the short drive from Marigot. Think wide stretches of sand, turquoise water, and just the right balance of lively and laid-back.

Maho Beach: A One-and-Done Stop

We couldn’t skip Maho Beach, famous for planes flying dramatically low overhead from Princess Juliana International Airport.

It’s undeniably unique—but also crowded, chaotic, and at times, honestly reckless. Watching planes land from that close is thrilling for about five minutes… after that, the touristy atmosphere and risky behavior were enough for us to move on.

Getting Around: Renting a Car is Essential

To truly experience both sides of St. Martin—and to make the most of your time—you’ll want a car.

Distances are short, but the freedom to explore hidden beaches, local markets, and spontaneous lunch spots makes a huge difference.

Compare rental prices here.

A Quick Note on Water Issues

Prior to our stay, we heard about occasional water shut-offs on the French side due to political and infrastructure challenges.

While it’s worth being aware of, and in fact, did occur while we were there, it didn’t significantly impact our trip—and it wouldn’t stop us from visiting the island again. Just something to confirm with your accommodation when booking.

The Anguilla Day Trip: A Must-Do Experience

One of the absolute highlights of our trip was a short ferry ride to Anguilla.

The journey itself is quick and easy, but what awaits feels like a completely different world.

The people were genuinely some of the friendliest and most welcoming we’ve encountered anywhere. There’s a calm, unspoiled feel to the island that’s increasingly rare.

Shoal Bay: Worth the Hype

Shoal Bay fully lives up to its reputation as one of the most beautiful beaches in the Caribbean.

Powdery white sand, impossibly clear water, and a sense of space that lets you truly unwind—it’s the kind of place that makes you rethink rushing back.

We went for the day, but next time, we’d absolutely stay a few nights.

The island has a completely different pace compared to St. Martin. It’s quieter, more refined, and feels like a bucket list destination. Waking up near Shoal Bay or along one of the island’s other pristine beaches would be worth slowing the trip down for.

We’d likely look for a boutique beachfront stay—somewhere relaxed but elevated, with easy access to the water and local restaurants.

Browse the best places to stay in Anguilla.

The Tannins and Travel Takeaway

Would we go back? Absolutely.

St. Martin offers a rare combination of culture, cuisine, and beach life. Add in a day (or better yet, a couple nights) in Anguilla, and you’ve got a Caribbean trip that feels both indulgent and authentic.

If you’re planning a similar trip, be sure to check out my carry-on only packing list—it makes traveling between islands effortless.